Taking on new clients
Back to blog
SalesCold Email

Before You Hire a Lead Gen Agency, Ask These 5 Questions

Cedric LausterNovember 6, 20267 min read

TL;DR: Most problems with a lead gen agency are visible before you sign, if you ask the right questions. Ask what exactly counts as a meeting, who answers the replies and whether you see all of them, who is on the list and whether the emails are verified, what happens to the domains, mailboxes and list when you stop, and what happens if it does not work. Vague answers to any of these are your answer. And before any of it, check that your own sales calls close, because no agency can fix that part.

Key Takeaways

  • Get the definition of a "meeting" in writing: who counts, whether no-shows count, and who decides whether a meeting fits.
  • You should see every reply, not a curated list, and interested replies should get an answer within minutes.
  • Ask who is on the list and whether every email address is verified before it is sent to.
  • Ask who owns the sending domains, the mailboxes and the lead list after the contract ends.
  • A guarantee is only as good as its fine print: what number, by when, and what you pay if it is missed.
  • If your sales calls rarely close, fix that before you pay anyone for meetings.

On Wednesday I wrote that before you pay anyone for meetings, me included, you should look at what happened in your last 10 to 20 sales calls. This post is about the next step: once you know more meetings would help, how do you pick who books them?

I have written before about what usually went wrong when a lead gen agency booked zero meetings. That post is for after the fact. These are the questions I would ask before signing, as the buyer, and they are the questions I expect prospects to ask me.

1. What exactly counts as a meeting?

This sounds obvious until you read the contract. "10 meetings" can mean 10 calls with decision makers in your target market who show up. It can also mean 10 replies, 10 calendar slots that got booked whether anyone came or not, or 10 calls with people who would never buy what you sell.

Ask for the definition in writing:

  • Does the person have to fit the target market you agreed on, and who decides that?
  • Does a no-show count?
  • Does a meeting you book yourself from a reply they forwarded count?

If the agency books meetings by dropping invites into people's calendars without them picking a time, ask how many of those meetings actually happen. A meeting the person chose themselves is the one they show up to. That is why I only put a meeting in someone's calendar after they have accepted a time in writing or booked it through the link.

2. Who answers the replies, how fast, and can I see all of them?

A cold email campaign produces replies of every kind: interested, not now, wrong person, unsubscribe, out of office. Some agencies show you only the replies they count as positive. Ask to see all of them. The negative replies tell you whether the list and the message are right, and the "not now" replies are future clients if somebody keeps track of them.

Then ask who answers the interested ones, and how fast. Someone who says "sure, tell me more" and hears back the next afternoon has usually moved on. I answer interested replies within minutes, with two concrete times and a booking link. More on how positive replies turn into booked meetings.

3. Who is on the list, and are the emails verified?

Ask to see the list criteria before anything goes out: which industries, which company sizes, which job titles. A list built on the wrong criteria gets replies from people who will never buy, and those look like results until you are on the calls.

Then ask whether every address is checked before it is sent to. Sending to addresses that bounce wears out the sending domains and drags down everything else in the campaign. I only send to addresses verified as valid.

4. What happens to the domains, mailboxes and list when we stop?

Cold email should never go out from your main domain. It goes out from separate sending domains that look like yours, each with its own mailboxes and warmup. Here is how that setup protects your domain.

Those sending domains, the warmed mailboxes and the lead list all took time and money to build. Ask who owns them when the contract ends. If the answer is the agency, you start from zero the day you leave, including the weeks of warmup. That is not automatically bad, but you should know it before you sign. Also ask what happens to the people who replied "not now". If they stay with the agency, so does your future pipeline.

5. What happens if it does not work?

Many agencies offer a guarantee. Read what it actually says:

  • What number is guaranteed, and by when?
  • What do you pay if the number is missed: nothing, a partial refund, or more months of work for free?
  • How long is the contract, and can you leave if the results are not there?

Also ask when they expect to know whether the campaign works. A campaign judged after a few hundred emails has not been tested. I judge a campaign at 1,000 to 2,000 people. An agency that cannot tell you how many people it will reach before it draws a conclusion is guessing.

The question to ask yourself first

None of these questions matter if your sales calls do not close. An agency can fill your calendar, but it cannot run your call, send your proposal or follow up on it. If you are not sure where your deals stop, start with the check from Wednesday's post before you talk to anyone about meetings.

How to read the answers

You are not looking for perfect answers. You are looking for specific ones. "We'll see" on the meeting definition, "we handle the replies" without access, or "the domains are part of our infrastructure" without a word about what happens later are all answers in themselves. A good partner answers these in a sentence or two, puts them in the contract, and is not surprised that you asked.

What is the next step?

If you want to go through these questions with me, and hear how I answer each one, book a call with me.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I ask a lead generation agency before hiring them?

Ask what exactly counts as a meeting, who answers the replies and whether you can see all of them, who is on the list and whether the emails are verified, who owns the sending domains, mailboxes and list after the contract ends, and what happens if the guarantee is missed.

What counts as a qualified meeting in lead generation?

There is no standard definition, which is why it has to be in the contract. A useful one is a call with a decision maker in the target market you agreed on, who shows up. Ask whether no-shows and people outside your target market count toward the number.

Should I see all the replies from my cold email campaign?

Yes. Negative and "not now" replies tell you whether the list and the message are right, and "not now" replies can turn into clients later. An agency that only shows you positive replies is choosing what you get to see.

Who should own the cold email domains and lead list?

Ask before you sign. If the agency owns the sending domains, the warmed mailboxes and the list, you start from zero when you leave, including the warmup time. Get ownership in writing either way.

How long before I know if a lead gen agency is working?

That depends on how many people the campaign reaches, not on how many weeks have passed. I judge a campaign at 1,000 to 2,000 people. Ask the agency how many people it will reach before it draws a conclusion.

Can a lead gen agency fix a low close rate?

No. An agency can bring you conversations, but it cannot run your sales calls or follow up on your proposals. If your calls rarely close, fix that first, then pay for more meetings.

Cedric Lauster

Cedric Lauster

Founder, Emmauris

LinkedIn →
Blog

Want this for your business?

Book a free strategy call. No pitch, no obligation.

Book a Free Call
Book a Call