Taking on new clients
Back to blog
SalesCold Email

More Meetings Won't Grow Your Firm If Your Sales Calls Don't Close

Cedric LausterNovember 4, 20267 min read

TL;DR: If your sales calls rarely turn into clients, booking more of them mostly gets you a fuller calendar. Before you pay for more meetings, check where people drop out between "interested" and "signed": replies that never become a meeting, meetings that don't show, calls that end with "let me think about it", proposals that arrive late, and proposals nobody follows up on. Fix the step where they drop out first. Once your calls close, more meetings are worth paying for.

Key Takeaways

  • More meetings only grow your firm when the meetings you already have turn into clients.
  • Doubling your calls at the same close rate doubles your clients and your time on calls. Fixing the close gets you more clients with the same calendar.
  • Most leaks sit after the first "yes": slow replies, no-shows, vague calls, late proposals and no follow-up.
  • Write down what happened in your last 10 to 20 sales conversations before you buy any lead source. It tells you which problem you have.
  • If your calls close and your calendar is empty, you have a meeting problem, and that is when outbound pays.

Booking more meetings won't grow your firm. Not if your sales calls don't close.

That sounds like a strange thing to say for someone who books meetings for a living. But when someone tells me they need more meetings, the first thing I want to know is what happened to the last ten. The answer tells me more than anything else on the call, because more meetings are only worth something if the process behind them works.

Why more meetings can make things worse

Simple arithmetic first. Say you have 10 sales calls a month and 1 of them becomes a client.

  • Double the meetings to 20 a month at the same close, and you get 2 clients. You also spend twice as much of your week on calls.
  • Keep 10 calls a month but get 3 of 10 to sign, and you get 3 clients with the same calendar.

More meetings into a process that leaks also costs you in less obvious ways. Every prospect only gets one first impression, so the leads you paid for are used up whether they signed or not. And when the new meetings still don't turn into clients, the natural conclusion is that the leads were bad. You switch vendors, the new vendor has the same result, and the real problem never gets looked at.

Where people drop out between "interested" and "signed"

These are the five places I check, in the order a prospect goes through them.

1. Interested replies that never become a meeting

Someone says "sure, tell me more" and gets an answer the next afternoon. By then the moment has passed. When a prospect replies with interest, I answer within minutes, with two concrete times and a booking link, so saying yes takes one click. More on turning positive replies into booked meetings.

2. Booked meetings that don't show

The meeting the person picked themselves is the one they show up to. An invite you put in their calendar without them choosing the time is your commitment, not theirs, and you can end up being the only one on the call. So I only put a meeting in someone's calendar after they have accepted a specific time in writing, or booked it through the link.

3. Calls that end with "let me think about it"

This one is usually not about the prospect. It happens when the call has no clear shape: no clear offer, no price, no next step. Before the call, know what you would offer this person, what it costs, and what you want them to decide. On the call, ask about their situation before you talk about yours. At the end, agree on a next step with a date, even if that step is "I send the proposal tomorrow and we talk Thursday".

For a reference point, Alex Hormozi says that if you close 30 to 40% of your sales calls, you are priced about right, and that much higher than that usually means your price is too low. He is talking about pricing, not about lead sources, but it gives you a sense of what a working sales call looks like.

4. Proposals that arrive late or say too little

A proposal that shows up a week after the call reads like the deal wasn't a priority. Send it in writing, with the price in it, and tell the prospect on the call when it will arrive. Hormozi's advice when a second step is needed is to commit to delivering the quote by a specific time the next day, and he says he can almost guarantee that this speed raises close rates.

5. Proposals nobody follows up on

Silence after a proposal is not a no. Busy people read a proposal, mean to answer and then their week happens. I follow up on each of the four days after I send a proposal, short and in the same email thread, so it is always on top of their inbox. When they answer, I take it from there myself.

How to tell which problem you have

Take your last 10 to 20 sales conversations and write one line for each:

  • Did the interested reply become a meeting?
  • Did they show up?
  • Did they get a proposal?
  • Did they sign, and if not, why not?

Then look at where the line usually stops.

  • Most people show up and sign, but there are few of them. You have a meeting problem. More meetings will turn into more clients.
  • Plenty of calls, few signatures. You have a closing problem. Fix the step where it stops before you pay for a single extra meeting.
  • You cannot fill in the list. That is the first thing to fix. Without it you cannot judge any lead source, including your own referrals.

When more meetings is the right answer

Once your calls close, everything changes. Each extra meeting is now worth roughly what your average meeting is worth, and that is the point where paying for outbound makes sense, because you can work out what a client costs you. Here is how many cold emails it takes to land a consulting client, and here is what usually went wrong when a first attempt at outbound failed.

What is the next step?

If you want to know whether more meetings would actually grow your firm right now, or whether there is something to fix first, book a call with me.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need more leads or a better sales process?

Look at your last 10 to 20 sales conversations. If most people who show up become clients but there are few of them, you need more leads. If you have plenty of calls but few of them sign, fix the sales process first, because more leads will only give you more calls that go nowhere.

What is a good close rate for consultants?

Alex Hormozi says that closing 30 to 40% of sales calls means a service business is priced about right, and that a much higher close rate usually means the price is too low. Treat it as a reference point, not a rule for every offer.

Why do booked sales calls not show up?

Often because the person never really chose the time. Meetings people book themselves, or accept in writing, show up far more often than invites they did not choose. Answering fast, with two concrete times and a booking link, also helps.

How fast should I send a proposal after a sales call?

Tell the prospect on the call when it will arrive and send it then, ideally the next day. Alex Hormozi recommends committing to a specific time the next day and says that speed raises close rates.

How often should I follow up on a proposal?

I follow up on each of the four days after I send a proposal, briefly and in the same email thread. Silence often means busy, not no, so keep it short and easy to answer.

Will cold email fix a sales problem?

No. Cold email brings you conversations. If those conversations rarely turn into clients, fix the call, the proposal and the follow-up first, and then add more meetings.

Cedric Lauster

Cedric Lauster

Founder, Emmauris

LinkedIn →
Blog

Want this for your business?

Book a free strategy call. No pitch, no obligation.

Book a Free Call
Book a Call